Why Client Retention Beats Constantly Chasing New Leads

Read time: < 3 mins

Most coaches put 80% of their energy into chasing new clients and only 20% into keeping the ones they already have. That’s backwards.

Here’s Why

• It costs 5–7x more to attract a new client than to retain an existing one.
• A 5% increase in retention can boost profits by 25–95% (Harvard Business Review).
• Churn creates constant pressure, always needing new leads, new sales, new launches.

That cycle is stressful, exhausting, and unsustainable.

Yet many coaches do exactly this. They build one course, deliver it, and then go straight back into content mode or marketing mode to find new people.

Why This Happens

Psychologically, chasing new clients feels safer. It looks like growth, it’s exciting, and you can hide behind content creation again. Retention work is quieter, less visible, but it’s where the real growth happens.

If your clients are getting results, they’ll want more from you. More access. More depth. More guidance on the next stage of their journey.

But if you don’t offer that next step, they’ll go looking elsewhere.

What Retention Looks Like in Practice

During a Course

• Live Q&A calls to keep people accountable
• Weekly emails that recap progress and remind them why they started
• Quick wins included in the content so students feel momentum early

In Communities

• Peer-to-peer support so they’re not learning alone
• Recognition of progress (badges, shoutouts, milestones)
• Spaces to ask questions and share wins, so learning doesn’t stop when the video ends

Beyond the First Product

• Graduates moving into masterminds, group coaching, or advanced courses
• Adding a community layer after a course ends, to keep the transformation alive
• Offering higher-value programmes for those who want more access to you

The Power of Escalation

One of the seven-figure coaches I work with has mastered this. His escalation of value and customer retention is off the scale. He doesn’t stop at one product or one community – he’s built a pathway that takes clients deeper and deeper, all the way up to becoming certified coaches who work under his brand.

That’s the ultimate retention and growth strategy: clients never “finish” with him, because there’s always a clear next step.

The Silent Sales Team

Retention isn’t just about programmes. It’s also about referrals. When you make it easy for clients to refer, and reward them for doing it, you create growth in the background. A robust referral system is like having a silent sales team working for you 24/7. Few coaches put the time into this, but it’s one of the most powerful growth levers you can pull.

The 70/30 Rule

Here’s a mindset shift I share with clients:

• 👉 Spend 70% of your time on retention and growth of existing clients
• 👉 Spend 30% of your time on new client acquisition

Why? Because happy clients don’t just stay – they buy more, bring referrals, and do your marketing for you.

The Takeaway

Retention isn’t just about completion rates. It’s about creating a momentum loop where your clients keep moving forward with you – whether that’s through advanced programmes, communities, or referral networks.

This is why I love Kajabi. It’s not just a content delivery system – it’s a growth machine. With the right strategy, you can build courses, communities, upsells, and referrals all in one place.

Stop chasing endlessly. Start thinking: “Where do I take my clients next?”

When you get this right, you don’t just build a course. You build a business that grows without constant stress and churn.

Your Next Step

Ready to turn your course into a growth engine?

Most coaches think about building once and selling once. The real opportunity is creating a client journey that keeps people engaged, moving forward, and asking for more.

This is exactly what I help coaches and training companies do inside Kajabi – building systems that aren’t just about content delivery, but about retention, referrals, and long-term growth.

👉 If you’re ready to stop chasing and start building a business that grows with less stress, book a call with me here.